With so many cookie sheets on the market, it can be hard to find the one that fits your baking needs. To help you pick the best stainless steel cookie sheet, we've compiled a list of the 6 top options for every budget and cooking style.
Plus, we included a buying guide with all the features you should look out for when selecting one.
Here are the best stainless steel cookie sheets you can buy in 2024:
- Best For Even Browning: Fox Run 44927
- Lightweight: Meleg Otthon 8541890391
- Best For Bigger Families: Wildone Baking Sheet Set of 2-Stainless Steel Cookie Sheet Baking Pan
- Easy To Clean: Norpro 3862
- Durable: All-Clad 11644906528
| 5 Best Stainless Steel Cookie Sheets | ||
|---|---|---|
Best For Even Browning | Fox Run 44927 | |
Lightweight | Meleg Otthon 8541890391 | |
Best For Bigger Families | Wildone Baking Sheet Set of 2-Stainless Steel Cookie Sheet Baking Pan | |
Easy To Clean | Norpro 3862 | |
Durable | All-Clad 11644906528 | |
Best For Even Browning: Fox Run 44927
- Even browning - 18/0 stainless steel construction
- Provide an easy grip - 3 rimmed sides
- It’s hard to peel off the label
The Fox Run 44927 isn't a cookie sheet that you have to worry about unevenly baked goods. Constructed of sturdy 18/0 stainless steel, it promotes even heat distribution for consistent baking and browning.
Besides this cookie sheet is warp- and corrosion-resistant and oven-safe to 536 degrees Fahrenheit.
It features 3 rimmed sides, providing a firm grip.
The classic rectangle shape is perfect for not just cookies but also vegetables, biscuits, macaroons, flatbreads, thin crust pizza, and French fries.
| Fox Run 44927 Specifications | |
|---|---|
Weight | 15.2 ounces |
Dimensions | 14" x 17" |
Oven-safe Temperature | 536 degrees Fahrenheit |
Highlight Features | 18/0 stainless steel construction 3 rimmed sides |
The Fox Run 44927 is ideal for anyone looking for an even-browning stainless steel cookie sheet.
Lightweight: Meleg Otthon 8541890391
- Very lightweight - 1.23 pounds
- Easy to handle - all-around curling design
- Able to prevent warping - the reinforced encapsulated steel rim
- The coating doesn’t last long
Looking for a heavy-duty yet lightweight stainless steel baking sheet that will never rust and be easy to maneuver? Check out the Meleg Otthon 8541890391.
This jelly roll pan is made of high-quality food grade stainless steel that conducts heat evenly, ensuring your baked goods come out perfectly every time.
Above all, it weighs only 1.23 pounds, which is a lot lighter than other counterparts on the market. This means you can easily move it from the oven to the dining table with no problems.
Plus, the all-around curling design makes it easy to handle and prevents scratches, while the reinforced encapsulated steel rim prevents warping.
| Meleg Otthon 8541890391 Specifications | |
|---|---|
Weight | 1.23 Pounds |
Dimensions | 14.25x11.22x2.36 inches |
Highlight Features | 1.23 pounds all-around curling design the reinforced encapsulated steel rim |
The Meleg Otthon 8541890391 won’t disappoint those in search of the most lightweight stainless steel cookie sheet.
Best For Bigger Families: Wildone Baking Sheet Set of 2-Stainless Steel Cookie Sheet Baking Pan
- Perfect for big families, baking shops, or buffets – a large size of 20 x 14 x 1 inches
- Comfortable to hold and transfer - the smooth roll edges
- Prevent food juice from leaking/spilling out - deep full sides
- It’s not scratch-resistant
- Wish it was a bit thicker
Enjoy making delicious home-cooked meals for your big family with the Wildone Baking Sheet Set of 2.
This set of two baking sheets are made of premium 18/0 stainless steel without any toxic materials. And their measurements are 20 x 14 x 1 inches - which is large enough for accommodating 12 cookies at the same time.
The mirror finish on the sheets makes them resistant to sticking, while the smooth roll edges make them comfortable to hold and transfer. Plus, the deep full sides prevent food juice from flowing everywhere
| Wildone Baking Sheet Set of 2-Stainless Steel Cookie Sheet Baking Pan Specifications | |
|---|---|
Weight | 4.49 Pounds |
Dimensions | 20 x 14 x 1 inches |
Highlight Features | a large size of 20 x 14 x 1 inches the smooth roll edges deep full sides |
All-in-all, the Wildone Baking Sheet Set of 2 is ideal for uses in big families, baking shops, or buffets.
Easy To Clean: Norpro 3862
- Easy to clean - a smooth and flat surface & 18/0 stainless steel construction
- Prevent cookies from sliding off unexpectedly - three-sided rim design
- Wish it was thicker
With the Norpro 3862, you'll save lots of time on after-cook cleanup tasks because it's very easy to clean.
Although hand washing is recommended, this cookie sheet features a smooth and flat surface that prevents sticking and makes cleaning a breeze.
The 18/0 stainless steel construction is also sturdy and rust-free to not wear out that quickly after many cleaning times.
We appreciate its three-sided rim design, which prevents cookies from sliding off.
At 16.75 x 12 x 0.5 inches, this cookie sheet is large enough to fit plenty of cookies, fries, pizza, biscuits, and more.
| Norpro 3862 Specifications | |
|---|---|
Weight | 1.41 pounds |
Dimensions | 16.75 x 12 x 0.5 inches |
Highlight Features | a smooth and flat surface & 18/0 stainless steel construction three-sided rim design |
If you are looking for a stainless steel cookie sheet that’s sturdy and easy to clean, the Norpro 3862 is our favorite pick.
Durable: All-Clad 11644906528
- Durable - 3 bonded layers of stainless steel and aluminum
- Reliable - handcrafted in the USA by a 50-year history cookware brand
- Able to withstand high heat - oven safe up to 600 degrees Fahrenheit
- Expensive
On the market for the most durable stainless steel cookie sheet? You should not dismiss the All-Clad 11644906528.
It's one of the rare options out there that are made from 3 bonded layers of stainless steel and aluminum for maximum durability and heat distribution. Better yet, it's handcrafted in the USA by All-Clad - a famous bonded cookware brand with almost 50 years of history.
This cookie sheet is oven safe up to 600 degrees Fahrenheit and dishwasher safe for easy cleaning.
As a plus, it features an angled edge, making it easy to take in and out of the oven.
| All-Clad 11644906528 Specifications | |
|---|---|
Weight | 2.4 Pounds |
Dimensions | 17 x 14 x 0.5 inches |
Oven-safe Temperature | up to 600°F |
Highlight Features | 3 bonded layers of stainless steel and aluminum handcrafted in the USA by a 50-year history cookware brand oven safe up to 600 degrees Fahrenheit |
The All-Clad 11644906528 stands out for its three-ply construction, making it the most durable stainless steel cookie sheet in our testing.
How To Choose The Best Stainless Steel Cookie Sheet?
Size
When it comes to cookie sheets, size definitely matters!
But with all the different sizes of cookie sheets on the market, how do you know which one is the best for your needs?
Here are a few things to take into consideration when choosing the size of your stainless steel cookie sheet:
Type Of Cookies You Plan On Baking
If you only bake small cookies, then a smaller cookie sheet will suffice. But if you like to bake large cookies, then you'll need a larger cookie sheet to accommodate them.
Number Of Cookies You Plan On Baking At One Time
If you only bake a few cookies at a time, then a smaller cookie sheet will do. But if you like to bake dozens of cookies at a time, then you'll need a larger cookie sheet to accommodate all of them.
Size Of Your Oven
Be sure to measure your oven before purchasing a stainless steel cookie sheet so that you know what size will fit inside it.
Your Personal Preference
Some people prefer smaller cookie sheets because they're easier to handle and clean. Others prefer larger cookie sheets because they can bake more cookies at one time. It's really up to you!
Oven-Safe Temperature Range
This is an important factor because you need to make sure that the cookie sheet can withstand the heat of your oven.
There are a few things that you need to keep in mind when you are looking at the oven-safe temperature range.
The first is that the higher the temperature, the more likely it is that the cookie sheet will warp. This means that you need to find a cookie sheet that has a high enough temperature rating so that it will not warp in your oven.
Next, the thickness of the cookie sheet can affect the oven-safe temperature range.
If the cookie sheet is too thin, it might not be able to withstand high temperatures. On the other hand, if the cookie sheet is too thick, it might not conduct heat well and could end up burning your cookies.
Other Factors
Baking Surface
Make sure to choose stainless steel cookie sheets with smooth surfaces to prevent sticking and make cleanup easier.
Durability
Stainless steel cookie sheets are made from a strong and durable material that won't warp or rust. They're perfect for baking large batches of cookies, and they're easy to clean.
Look for cookie sheets that are made from heavy-gauge stainless steel and have a smooth shiny surface.
Avoid cookie sheets that are made from thin gauge stainless steel or have a dull, brushed finish.
Which Brands Make The Best Stainless Steel Cookie Sheet?
Wildone
For those with a passion for baking, Wildone is a reliable stop-shop. The company specializes in bakeware and pantry items, aiming to provide trusted products that will last for years to come.
As a result of their deep involvement in this field, they have released a number of stylish and practical kitchen utensils in the past few years.
Norpro
Since 1973, Norpro has been providing high-quality kitchenware crafted with top-notch craftsmanship and superior materials at the best prices.
In addition to stocking over 1400 items and traveling the world to develop dozens of new, innovative products every year, Norpro also boasts a staff that is friendly and knowledgeable. They will always exceed every customer's expectations.
All-Clad
All-Clad began production in 1971, and has since become one of the most renowned manufacturers of cookware in the United States.
The brand truly believes in the saying “quality over quantity.” They do not rely on automation to manufacture their products, instead focusing on employing time-tested methods for higher quality items.
What All-Clad stands for is higher quality products with superior performance.
FAQs
Is it better to bake with aluminum or stainless steel?
Stainless steel is better to bake with than aluminum because steel is better at heat retention and more durable.
Does stainless steel give off toxins?
Yes, it does. Stainless steel gives off low levels of chromium and nickel, especially when used with acidic foods.
Do stainless steel cookie sheets rust?
Stainless steel cookie sheets can rust in certain conditions, such as when they’re exposed to damaging heat, moisture, grease, saline, or chemicals for a long time, but not as severely or quickly as regular steels.
Do stainless steel cookie sheets stick?
Yes, they do. Baked goods can stick to stainless steel cookie sheets, especially if they don’t have nonstick coating.
How do you make cookie sheets look new again?
This tutorial video will show you how to make a stained bakeware look like new again:
Conclusion
Steel cookie sheets are the ideal kitchen tool for anyone looking to make consistently delicious baked goods.
Not only do these non-stick materials provide an even heat distribution and a longer lifespan than aluminum models, but they can also be cleaned with ease.
With this in mind, it should come as no surprise that the best stainless steel cookie sheets on the market today boast durable construction and excellent results time after time.
So if you’re considering investing in one of these top of the line baking tools, check out our list of recommended products above; you won’t regret it!
Jane Orta
