• Kitchen
  • 6 Best Nonstick Cookie Sheets of 2024

6 Best Nonstick Cookie Sheets of 2024

By Jane OrtaLast update: 2023-12-23

Cookies are a classic treat that you can make easily in the comfort of your own home - but not without the right bakeware! If you're looking for the best nonstick cookie sheet that won't let you down, this article is here to help.

We review 6 best nonstick cookie sheets on the market and give you a buying guide so you know exactly what to look out for when making your purchase.

Here are the best nonstick cookie sheets you can buy in 2024:

  • Best For Large Batches (Ceramic Coating Sheet): Caraway Non-Stick Ceramic Baking Sheet
  • Easy To Clean (Ceramic Coating Sheet): casaWare 8901-8B
  • Best For Small Batches (Ceramic Coating Sheet): GreenLife CC003908-001
  • Easy To Grip (Non-Ceramic Coating Sheet): Rachael Ray 47576
  • Best For Even Heating (Non-Ceramic Coating Sheet): GoodCook 4514
  • Sturdy (Non-Ceramic Coating Sheet): USA Pan 1045QS
6 Best Nonstick Cookie Sheets
Best For Large Batches
Caraway Non-Stick Ceramic Baking Sheet
  • Ceramic Coating Sheet
Easy To Clean
casaWare 8901-8B
  • Ceramic Coating Sheet
Best For Small Batches
GreenLife CC003908-001
  • Ceramic Coating Sheet
Easy To Grip
Rachael Ray 47576
  • Non-Ceramic Coating Sheet
Best For Even Heating
GoodCook 4514
  • Non-Ceramic Coating Sheet
Sturdy
USA Pan 1045QS
  • Non-Ceramic Coating Sheet

Best For Large Batches: Caraway Non-Stick Ceramic Baking Sheet

Caraway Non-Stick Ceramic Baking Sheet
Caraway Non-Stick Ceramic Baking Sheet
Pros
  • Ideal for large batches – dimensions of 18
Cons
  • A bit pricey

With a large cooking surface of 18" x 13", the Caraway Non-Stick Ceramic Baking Sheet can accommodate 12-15 cookies simultaneously, making it a perfect choice for serving a crowd or a big family.

What's worth mentioning is, its nonstick coating doesn't contain toxins like cadmium, lead, PFAS, PFOA, or PTFE. This means no toxic materials could leach into your homemade cookies.

Note: This cookie sheet can withstand oven temperatures up to 550ºF.

Caraway Non-Stick Ceramic Baking Sheet Specifications

Weight

5.5 pounds

Dimensions

Large 18" x 13"

Materials

PFOA Free Ceramic

Oven-safe Temperature

up to 550ºF.

Highlight Features

dimensions of 18" x 13"

Oven-safe up to 550ºF

Verdict

The Caraway Non-Stick Ceramic Baking Sheet is our favorite pick for those looking for the best ceramic nonstick coating cookie sheet for large batches.

Easy To Clean: casaWare 8901-8B

casaWare 8901-8B
casaWare 8901-8B
Pros
  • Easy to clean - the brand's exclusive granite ceramic-coated baking surface
  • High fashion - eye-catching blue color
  • Dependable - European Union, California Proposition 65, and FDA-approved
Cons
  • The rims hold water
  • Not easy to hold

If you want something that requires less prep before baking and minimal scrubbing for a spotless clean, then the casaWare 8901-8B will be your best pick.

This commercial-weight 0.8mm pan features the brand's exclusive granite ceramic-coated baking surface that's for easy food release and effortless cleaning.

Plus, the eye-catching blue color makes it very high fashion.

You will be worried-free when using this cookie sheet because it's toxin-free and also European Union, California Proposition 65, and FDA-approved for safety.

casaWare 8901-8B Specifications

Weight

5.55 Pounds

Dimensions

13 Inch x 9 Inch

Materials

Carbon Steel

Oven-safe Temperature

450 F

Highlight Features

the brand's exclusive granite ceramic-coated baking surface

eye-catching blue color

European Union, California Proposition 65, and FDA-approved

Verdict

Our review team likes the casaWare 8901-8B because it’s both high function and high fashion. In particular, it’s very easy to clean.

Best For Small Batches: GreenLife CC003908-001

GreenLife CC003908-001
GreenLife CC003908-001
Pros
  • Perfect for small batches – dimensions of 9
Cons
  • The sheets don’t resist scratching well

The GreenLife CC003908-001 is a set of a toaster oven cookie sheet and a cookie sheet, all in the same size of 9" x 7". This makes it an excellent choice for those who want to bake small batches of cookies or/and reheat small items.

Both cookie sheets are made of durable, PFAS-free ceramic nonstick.

We like the wide rims that make it easy to grip the pan, while the turquoise color adds a pop of style to your kitchen.

GreenLife CC003908-001 Specifications

Weight

1.6 pounds

Dimensions

11 x 7.5 x 2 inches

Materials

Ceramic, PFAS Free Nonstick, Aluminum

Oven-safe Temperature

450 Degrees Fahrenheit

Highlight Features

dimensions of 9" x 7"

wide rims

turquoise color

Verdict

With dimensions of 9” x 7”, the GreenLife CC003908-001 is perfect for small batches.

Easy To Grip: Rachael Ray 47576

Rachael Ray 47576
Rachael Ray 47576
Pros
  • Easy to grip - bold-colored, oversized, and rubberized handles
  • Flexible – including three cookie pans in three different sizes
  • Warp-resistant – made of durable steel
Cons
  • The handles are a bit tricky to clean

The Rachael Ray 47576 stands out from other non-ceramic cookie sheets for its bold-colored, oversized, and rubberized handles, providing extra grips for a confident grasp.

In addition, these handles are oven safe to 500 degrees F, which means they stay cool to the touch without being melted in the oven.

This set includes three cookie sheets of different sizes, which we love because they can meet various baking needs.

Made from durable steel, these cookie sheets resist warping and feature long-lasting nonstick to last for years to come.

Rachael Ray 47576 Specifications

Weight

5 Pounds

Dimensions

18.25 x 11.5 x 1.75 inches

Materials

Alloy Steel

Oven-safe Temperature

500 degrees Fahrenheit.

Highlight Features

bold-colored, oversized, and rubberized handles

including three cookie pans in three different sizes

Verdict

The Rachael Ray 47576 boasts oversized and rubberized handles, making it very easy to grip.

Best For Even Heating: GoodCook 4514

GoodCook 4514
GoodCook 4514
Pros
  • Even-heating - a two-ply construction
  • Heat up quickly - textured bottom design
Cons
  • The cookie sheets easily slide around

The GoodCook 4514 is the perfect way to get evenly baked cookies every time.

The secret? These cookie sheets have a two-ply construction, allowing for even hot-air circulation during the baking process. From there, there are no cold or scorching spots, and cookies are baked evenly.

As a plus, these pans feature textured bottom designs for fast heating while retaining moisture to prevent the top from overheating.

GoodCook 4514 Specifications

Weight

4.24 pounds

Dimensions

16" x 14"

Materials

Carbon Steel

Oven-safe Temperature

410 degrees F

Highlight Features

a two-ply construction

textured bottom design

Verdict

If you are on the hunt for the best even-heating nonstick cookie sheet, the GoodCook 4514 is definitely our first pick.

Sturdy: USA Pan 1045QS

USA Pan 1045QS
USA Pan 1045QS
Pros
  • Sturdy - heavy gauge aluminized steel construction
  • Provide superior bake release - an Americoat coating
  • Reliable - made in the USA
Cons
  • Wish the finish lasted longer

The USA Pan 1045QS is made of heavy gauge aluminized steel that provides superior durability, along with outstanding bake performance.

It also has an Americoat coating, a silicone that's free of BPA, PFOA, and PTFE, and provides superior bake release.

Better yet, this cookie pan is made in the USA from globally sourced materials, which ensures quality.

USA Pan 1045QS Specifications

Weight

1 Pound

Dimensions

13 x 9 x 1 inches

Materials

Alloy Steel

Highlight Features

heavy gauge aluminized steel construction

an Americoat coating

made in the USA

Verdict

Made of heavy-gauge aluminized steel, the USA Pan 1045QS is extremely sturdy and durable.

How To Choose The Best Nonstick Cookie Sheet?

Which To Choose: Ceramic Or Non-ceramic Nonstick Cookie Sheets?

Nonstick cookie sheets can be made of either ceramic or non-ceramic materials.

Each material has its own set of benefits and drawbacks that you should consider when choosing the best option for your needs.

Ceramic nonstick cookie sheets are made of a durable glazed material that is highly resistant to sticking. They are also easy to clean and can be used in the oven or microwave.

However, they are not as effective at evenly distributing heat as other materials and can be more expensive.

Non-ceramic nonstick cookie sheets are made of a variety of materials, including aluminum, silicone, and steel.

Aluminum is a good choice for a cookie sheet because it conducts heat well and is affordable. However, it can warp over time if it gets too hot.

Steel is a more durable option, but it doesn't conduct heat as well as aluminum.

Some newer materials, such as silicone. This material usually has a nonstick coating that makes it easy to clean. However, it can be more expensive than aluminum or steel cookie sheets.

When choosing a material for your cookie sheet, consider how often you'll use it and how much you're willing to spend. Aluminum and steel are good choices for everyday use, while ceramic or silicone may be better for occasional use.

Size

There are many factors to consider when choosing the size of your nonstick cookie sheet.

The most important factor is the size of your oven. Make sure to measure your oven before purchasing a cookie sheet.

Another factor to consider is how many cookies you want to bake at one time. If you are only baking for yourself or a small family, a smaller cookie sheet may suffice. However, if you want to bake large batches of cookies, you will need a larger cookie sheet.

Some cookie sheets come in standard sizes, such as half-sheet or quarter-sheet pans. These sizes are helpful if you already know the dimensions of your oven and just need to find a cookie sheet that will fit.

Other cookie sheets are available in special sizes, such as round or shaped pans. These may be better suited for certain types of cookies or for more creative designs.

Weight

Heavier cookie sheets will distribute heat more evenly, resulting in better-baked cookies. They're also less likely to warp over time.

If you have the opportunity to hold the cookie sheet before you purchase it, do so.

Heftier models will feel heavier in your hand, and that's usually a good indicator of quality.

Other Factors

Shape

The shape of the cookie sheet is also something to consider. Some cookie sheets have raised sides and some have flat sides. The side you choose is a personal preference.

Ease of grip

The last thing to think about is how easy the cookie sheet is to grip.

This is important because you don’t want the cookie sheet slipping out of your hands when you are trying to remove cookies from it.

Look for a cookie sheet that has a lip or edge that you can grip easily.

Which Brands Make The Best Nonstick Cookie Sheet?

Caraway

Caraway is dedicated to designing and manufacturing home goods. They stand out for providing non-toxic products as well as the focus on sustainability. Their manufacturing process is proven to produce up to 60% less carbon dioxide than traditional non-stick coatings.

Rachael Ray

We’re touched by the story full of humanity of Rachael Ray.

With the sale of Rachael Ray Nutrish®, a private foundation called Rachael Ray Foundation (RRF), which was founded in 2016, will receive full funding for the foundation.

RRF's mission is to help animals in need in addition to helping with disaster relief efforts and providing assistance in emergency situations involving animals.

FAQs

Should cookie sheets be non-stick?

Yes, they should. Nonstick cookie sheets keep the baked goods from sticking, making them easier to release when done the baking process.

How do I make my cookie sheets not stick?

To make your cookie sheets not stick, you can use a food-grade silicone non-stick mat or line the sheet with parchment paper.

What baking sheets do restaurants use?

Restaurants often use carbon steel baking sheets because this material is much sturdier and more durable than other metal types.

Why is my non-stick cookie sheet not non-stick anymore?

There are many reasons making a nonstick cookie sheet not nonstick anymore, such as:

  • Storing baked goods in the pan
  • Baking the sheet at too high heat
  • Using metal utensils on the cookie sheet
  • Improper maintenance

Should I oil a non-stick cookie sheet?

No, you shouldn’t. It’s not necessary to oil a nonstick cookie sheet. But this practice might come in handy for a regular cookie sheet.

Conclusion

Choosing the best nonstick cookie sheet is an important decision for any baker. With so many options available, it can be hard to determine which one is right for you.

We hope that this article has provided you with enough information to make an informed decision and find a great nonstick cookie sheet that will serve your baking needs. With a little bit of research, you should be able to pick out the perfect one for all your delicious creations!


Related Articles