Small yet handy, a butter dish keeps your butter fresh for a longer time at room temperature and even an accent in your kitchen table. If you’re looking for the best butter dish for counter, here are some of our listed options:
Here are the best butter dishes for counter you can buy in 2024:
- Largest Capacity (Ceramic Butter Dish): DOWAN Butter Dish
- Smallest Capacity (Ceramic Butter Dish): Butter Bell-The Original Butter Bell Crock by L. Tremain Light Blue
- Easy To Clean (Ceramic Butter Dish): PriorityChef Ceramic Butter Dish
- Durable (Glass Butter Dish): Royalty Art 28049
- Vintage Design (Glass Butter Dish): Bezrat BT406
- Best For Narrow Butter Sticks (Glass Butter Dish): KANGAROO 10254
- Best For Long Butter Sticks (Plastic Butter Dish): OXO 11122500
- Best For Short & Stubby Sticks (Plastic Butter Dish): Rubbermaid 1777193
- Mid-Century Design (Plastic Butter Dish): Butter Hub Butter Dish
| 9 Best Butter Dishes For Counter | ||
|---|---|---|
Largest Capacity | DOWAN Butter Dish
| |
Smallest Capacity | Butter Bell-The Original Butter Bell Crock by L. Tremain Light Blue
| |
Easy To Clean | PriorityChef Ceramic Butter Dish
| |
Durable | Royalty Art 28049
| |
Vintage Design | Bezrat BT406
| |
Best For Narrow Butter Sticks | KANGAROO 10254
| |
Best For Long Butter Sticks | OXO 11122500
| |
Best For Short & Stubby Sticks | Rubbermaid 1777193
| |
Mid-Century Design | Butter Hub Butter Dish
| |
Largest Capacity: DOWAN Butter Dish
- Holding a big pound of butter - The 4” W x 6” L inside dimensions
- Keeping butter fresh long – airtight silicone seal
- Elegant looking – the natural acacia wooden texture
- A bit heavier than it needs to be
This butter dish is suitable for those looking for a larger butter keeper.
The 4” W x 6” L inside dimensions allow it to comfortably hold a butter stick from 3.5" x 1.5" to 4.75" x 1.25" in size, which is perfectly suitable for the whole family.
The lid is also our favorite. The silicone seal around it keeps the butter fresh really long. Meanwhile, its beautiful acacia wooden texture adds to a touch of elegance to the dish’s overall look. With this option, you’ve got 6 color options to choose from.
| DOWAN Butter Dish Specifications | |
|---|---|
Dimensions | 6.5 x 4 x 3.1 inches |
Capacity | (3.5" x 1.5") or (4.75" x 1.25") butter sticks |
Highlight Features | The 4” W x 6” L inside dimensions airtight silicone seal the natural acacia wooden texture |
Offering the largest capacity, the DOWAN Butter Dish can hold a big pound of butter, making it a perfect choice for the whole family.
Smallest Capacity: Butter Bell-The Original Butter Bell Crock by L. Tremain Light Blue
- Holding an around 125-gram butter stick
- Unique & beautiful look - the Provencal rustic design
- Pricey
Contrasting to our previous pick, this butter dish from Butter Bell has the smallest capacity. It can hold a petite-sized butter stick of around 125 grams. The patented design traps the natural moisture of the butter, keeping it fresh and spreadable without a refrigerator.
The close lid is a nicely added bonus.
Butter dishes from The Original Butter Bell Crock’s collection by L. Tremain always stand out for the unique Provencal rustic look inspired from French country kitchens. And, this one isn’t an exception. It looks attractive on the table.
| Butter Bell-The Original Butter Bell Crock by L. Tremain Light Blue Specifications | |
|---|---|
Dimensions | 3.94 x 3.94 x 4.13 inches |
Capacity | 1/2 cup or 125 grams |
Highlight Features | Holding an around 125-gram butter stick the Provencal rustic design |
We were pleasantly impressed with the Butter Bell - The Original Butter Bell Crock by L. Tremain Light Blue for providing the smallest capacity.
Easy To Clean: PriorityChef Ceramic Butter Dish
- Easy to clean – dishwasher-friendly design
- No sliding while you’re cutting butter – a wide base with grippy finish
- Easy to grasp – a top-handle on the lid
- The unglazed bottom of the dish could scratch other kitchen utensils
If you don’t need anything fancy, just something affordable, quality, and not a pain to clean, then the PriorityChef fits the bill.
It’s 100% dishwasher-safe, though you can quickly rinse it under running water in no longer than 2 minutes. The stain-resistant finish does a great job of avoiding smearing butter on the inside of the lid, which is a great plus.
In terms of the size, this option is large enough to hold both Western/ Eastern styles of butter sticks. The lid fits firmly and the top-handle is easy to grasp.
The rough-texture bottom of the dish is quite controversial as it provides better grips while you’re cutting butter but could riskily scratch your kitchen countertop at a time.
| PriorityChef Ceramic Butter Dish Specifications | |
|---|---|
Dimensions | 9.1 x 5.75 x 5.4 inches |
Capacity | 1 butter stick |
Highlight Features | dishwasher-friendly design a wide base with grippy finish a top-handle on the lid |
We highly recommend the PriorityChef Ceramic Butter Dish for those who are looking for an easy-to-clean ceramic butter dish for the counter.
Durable: Royalty Art 28049
- Durable, odorless, and stain-resistant – high-grade borosilicate glass material
- Quick cleaning - seamless design with no deep crevices
- Easy to replace or access butter – a knob on the lid
- Wish the handle was slightly bigger
- Pretty narrow
We’ve tested a lot of glass butter dishes from different brands, and this one is the most durable ever.
Made of high-grade borosilicate glass material, the product is incredibly odorless, stain-resistant, and heavy-duty. It is also easy to clean thanks to the seamless design with no deep crevices.
As an added bonus, it brings a sleek and timeless look to your kitchen table.
The small grip on its lid is a practical addition for easy removal when you are replacing butter when done or getting it.
| Royalty Art 28049 Specifications | |
|---|---|
Dimensions | 8 x 3.8 x 4 inches |
Capacity | 2 butter sticks |
Highlight Features | high-grade borosilicate glass material seamless design with no deep crevices a knob on the lid |
The durability offered by the Royalty Art 28049 is extraordinary, making it one of the best glass butter dishes out there.
Vintage Design: Bezrat BT406
- Unique vintage look – a butterfly handle & a sparkly tray with rich engraved design
- Easy to grip & space-saving - a 3” wide cover with two crystal-etched sides
- The corners of the dish are prone to chip
The Bezrat BT406 is a beautiful well-designed piece of craftsmanship that looks gorgeous on any kitchen table. The dish distinguishes itself from the rest for the unique butterfly handle and the sparkly tray with rich engraved design. An artsy way to serve your butter in style!
But there’s more!
The product is made of BPA-free glass material, which means it doesn’t contain lead or any toxic substances to harm your health. It’s also odor-resistant.
Though there’s no top knob on the lid, this butter dish comes with a reasonably wide cover with two crystal-etched sides for providing comfortable grip in a more space-saving fashion. We love it!
| Bezrat BT406 Specifications | |
|---|---|
Dimensions | 7 x 4 x 3 inches |
Capacity | 1-¾-inch butter sticks |
Highlight Features | a butterfly handle & a sparkly tray with rich engraved design a 3” wide cover with two crystal-etched sides |
Aside from quality and function, we also tested all the contenders for aesthetics. For a unique vintage look, we find the Bezrat BT406 is hard to beat
Best For Narrow Butter Sticks: KANGAROO 10254
- Ideal for narrow butter sticks – the 3.58” width of the tray
- Able to be used for serving garnishes – the seamless cover with a flat bottom
- Struggling to remove the lid with a wet hand
This butter dish from KANGAROO comes in the right size for storing narrower butter sticks, but it’s also great to hold a standard-size one or a block of cream cheese when in need.
Furthermore, as the top cover has a flat bottom, you can flip it over and use it as a garnish, which is versatile.
The glass material feels thick, heavy, and sturdy with no pointy edges to result in any potential chips during use. It’s also BPA-free, food-safe, and dishwasher-friendly like other picks in this category.
There’s just one minor drawback: no knob or anything like that on the lid for grip, which could be a nuisance if you want to remove this part with a wet hand.
| KANGAROO 10254 Specifications | |
|---|---|
Dimensions | 7.28 x 5.39 x 3.58 inches |
Capacity | 1 butter stick |
Highlight Features | the 3.58” width of the tray the seamless cover with a flat bottom |
The best glass butter dish for narrow sticks in our review is hands down the KANGAROO 10254
Best For Long Butter Sticks: OXO 11122500
- Ideal for long butter sticks – the dimensions of 7.87 x 2.56 x 2 inches
- Keeping the butter in place, but still easy to remove the lid – a well-designed top and bottom stopper
- Easy to cut butter - measurement markings
- The base should be heavier to not be easily knocked off
Kitchen utensils from OXO have been known for top-notch quality and classy-looking design at highly competitive price points. And, the OXO 11122500 is a typical example.
But one thing we love about this product is that it’s extended and narrow to perfectly fit long butter sticks. The stopper is great; it keeps the butter and the cover in place when you move the dish around, but ensures the lid is still easy to remove.
The measurement markings are a nice addition, helping you to cut butter into equal pieces effortlessly.
| OXO 11122500 Specifications | |
|---|---|
Dimensions | 7.87 x 2.56 x 2 inches |
Capacity | 1 butter stick |
Highlight Features | the dimensions of 7.87 x 2.56 x 2 inches a stopper measurement markings |
If you’re looking for a high-quality plastic butter stick specifically made for long butter sticks, look no further than the OXO 11122500
Best For Short & Stubby Sticks: Rubbermaid 1777193
- Suitable for short and stubby sticks – the measurement of 7.79 x 2.09 x 3.06 inches
- Easy to clean - dishwasher-friendly material
- Hard to remove the lid
If you’re looking for a high-quality plastic butter dish that gives a great fit to those short and stubby sticks like Land O'Lakes, then consider the Rubbermaid 1777193.
It is measured by 7.79 x 2.09 x 3.06 inches and features a tall, thick base with wrap-around stopper type of design – which keeps the lid tighter. But that tightness could make the lid hard to open sometimes.
Though made of plastic, the Rubbermaid 177 is dishwasher-friendly.
| Rubbermaid 1777193 Specifications | |
|---|---|
Dimensions | 7.79 x 2.09 x 3.06 inches |
Capacity | 1 butter stick |
Highlight Features | the measurement of 7.79 x 2.09 x 3.06 inches dishwasher-friendly material |
For short and stubby sticks, the Rubbermaid 1777193 is the shiniest contender in our review.
Mid-Century Design: Butter Hub Butter Dish
- Timeless mid-century aesthetics
- Keep your butter knife quickly accessible – a magnetic lid
- Make scrapping, ramping, and scooping butter easier – a stopper with inner curved edges
- The magnet could be stronger
- The included butter knife feels cheap
This ultra-modern butter dish from Butter Hub will not only keep butter soft and easily spreadable for at least two weeks but also look great on your countertop.
We love its timeless mid-century design, just as much as the thoughtful magnetic lid where you can effortlessly attach a butter knife onto for easy access.
On the other hand, the four elevated feet keeps your countertop from smearing butter and the stopper with inner edges make scrapping, ramping, and scooping butter easier.
| Butter Hub Butter Dish Specifications | |
|---|---|
Dimensions | 7.05 x 3.11 x 2.56 inches |
Capacity | 1 butter stick |
Highlight Features | Timeless mid-century aesthetics a magnetic lid a stopper with inner curved edges |
Search for a timeless mid-century plastic butter dish that packs a bunch? Our favorite pick is the Butter Hub Butter Dish
How To Choose The Best Butter Dish For Counter?
Material
Butter dishes are varied in material options, including stainless-steel, glass, stoneware, ceramic, and plastic. Each comes in specific strengths and weaknesses.
- Stainless-steel: adaptable to any kitchen theme, easy to clean, and strong
- Glass: luxurious-looking, sleek, and long-lasting
- Stoneware: perfectly match marble patterns and durable
- Ceramic: long-lasting and sturdy. Ideal for fancy dinners
- Plastic: shatterproof, lightweight, and budget-friendly
A pro-tip is to pick the one that best fits your needs and lifestyles.
Sizes And Shapes
It’s impossible to pick a “one-size-fit-all” butter dish due to the variety of butter sticks’ shapes and sizes.
For the sake of this discussion, there are three common options:
- European sticks: 8 ounces’ weight in a wide, flat shape
- West Coast sticks: 4 ounces’ weight in a short and fat shape
- East Coast sticks: 4 ounces’ weight in a thinner shape
When considering the size and shape of your go-to butter dish, ask yourself what size butter sticks it’ll fit and how many.
Ease Of Cleaning
Butter could be messy.
It leaves a smudge on the knife edge, your fingers, and even the floor or countertop if it unfortunately falls off the dish. The solution? Look for a butter dish that can keep it staying in place.
Pay attention to these features: a stopper, leveraged feet, an airtight lid.
Which Brands Make The Best Butter Dish For Counter?
DOWAN
With over 30 years’ expertise, DOWAN becomes one of the most popular manufacturers for hand-made ceramic products. They have partnered with the best artisans in the world and featured in Stockhouse, Markets Insider, CNN, Market Watch, etc.
Butter Bell
Butter Bell is a brand dedicated to manufacturing butter dishes. A reliable address for customers to shop from an avalanche of styles and colors with unique design. Their products are beloved by world’s top chefs like Peter Roelant, Laurent Gras, and Michael Roussel.
PriorityChef
PriorityChef is a small, family-owned business specializing in kitchenware. But we’re quite impressed by their product lines which are various, high-quality, and aesthetic. Above all, the brand stands behind what they make by providing a 100%, no questions asked money back guarantee.
FAQs
Is it safe to leave butter out in a butter dish?
Yes, it is. Butter is safe to leave out in a butter dish at room temperature, according to the USDA. But take note that it only lasts for 1-2 days, so make sure to use them all within that period of time.
Does a butter dish need to be airtight?
Yes, it does. A butter dish needs to be always airtight to keep the butter fresh and lasting the longest, as well as protecting the food from insects or curious pets.
Where can I store a butter dish?
You can store a butter dish on a counter or in a cupboard.
What type of butter goes in a butter dish?
Both salted and unsalted butter can go in a butter dish, but the former does better.
How do I keep butter soft on the counter?
To keep butter soft on the counter, store it in the top bowl and keep it well-covered with a lid. Meanwhile, fill the bottom bowl with cold water.
Conclusion
While reviewing these products, we tried to imagine what other consumers could require on their butter dish: aesthetics, ease of cleaning, slip-resistance properties, etc.
We also interviewed some experts for advice, then analyzed the information, and shared with you through this article.
Hope that the list of best butter dishes for counter above are helpful to you. Thanks for reading!
