6 Best Breakfast Sandwich Makers of 2023

Last update: 2023-01-31

Is the best breakfast sandwich maker a worthy and long-term investment?

Yes.

Apart from serving breakfast every day, this type of machine can help you fry eggs and grill many foods on the cooking surface to make a quick meal for your family’s gatherings. Depending on your needs, pick one from the list below:

Here are the best breakfast sandwich makers you can buy in 2023:

  • Compact Design (Electric Sandwich Maker): Hamilton Beach
  • Best For Family (Electric Sandwich Maker): Chefman
  • Best For Couples (Electric Sandwich Maker): Gotham Steel
  • Easy To Clean (Sandwich Maker for Gas Stoves): Yoshikawa
  • Best For Meat & Cheese Sandwiches (Sandwich Maker for Gas Stoves): Happy Sales
  • Ultra Lightweight (Sandwich Maker for Gas Stoves): Yoshikawa Atsu Atsu
6 Best Breakfast Sandwich Makers
Compact Design
Hamilton Beach
  • Electric Sandwich Maker
Best For Family
Chefman
  • Electric Sandwich Maker
Best For Couples
Gotham Steel
  • Electric Sandwich Maker
Easy To Clean
Yoshikawa SJ2408
  • Sandwich Maker for Gas Stoves
Best For Meat & Cheese Sandwiches
Happy Sales
  • Sandwich Maker for Gas Stoves
Ultra Lightweight
Yoshikawa Atsu Atsu
  • Sandwich Maker for Gas Stoves

Compact Design: Hamilton Beach

Hamilton Beach
Hamilton Beach
Pros
  • Not cause a mess
  • Easy to clean and use
  • Clear and well-written instructions
  • Inexpensive
  • Well-made and high-quality material
Cons
  • Not for large pieces of breads

Do you have a small kitchen? Or do you want to keep your space at a minimum? The Hamilton Beach Electric Sandwich Maker can help you save more room thanks to its compact design. Specifically, its size is 7.3"D x 6.3"W x 5.6"H.

In spite of the small footprint, I am sure that you can eat your fill. This is a layered machine that can cook many ingredients. For example, you can fry an egg with cheese and a cut-half piece of bread on the top and meat with another piece of bread at the bottom.

Hamilton Beach Specifications

Weight

3.2 Pounds

Dimensions

7.3"D x 6.3"W x 5.6"H

Materials

Nonstick

Wattage

600 watts

Number of Sandwiches

1

Highlight Features

Removable parts

Verdict

Despite a small size, the Hamilton Beach Electric Sandwich Maker can make a sandwich with full ingredients.

Best For Family: Chefman

Pros
  • Nice look
  • Easy to use and store
  • Compact size
Cons
  • Hard to clean because you can’t remove the plate

What is the best sandwich maker for a family?

Whether your family is small or large, there are over 2 people for sure. So, you want to make at least 2 sandwiches in a turn, right? The closed cooking surface of this Chefman electric sandwich maker is 5.5'' x 8.75'' that is ideal for making 2 sandwiches at a time. For a 4-people family, you just need to make twice to get 4 sandwiches, so it’s quicker than using a single model.

If your family usually has small gatherings, this machine is also useful. Its lay-flat cooking surface (10'' x 8.75'') allows you to fry many foods on it to serve a few people with a quick meal.

Chefman Specifications

Weight

4 Pounds

Dimensions

10"D x 13"W x 4"H

Materials

Stainless Steel

Wattage

1000 watts

Number of Sandwiches

2

Highlight Features

Closed cooking surface: 5.5'' x 8.75''

Lay-flat surface: 10'' x 8.75''

The non-stick coated grill plates

The removable drip tray

Verdict

Despite a compact size, the cooking surface of the Chefman Electric Sandwich Maker is large enough to cook many foods at a go.

Best For Couples: Gotham Steel

Gotham Steel
Gotham Steel
Pros
  • Easy to use
  • Good size
Cons
  • Difficult to clean

Are you looking for a sandwich maker for a 2-people family?

The Gotham Steel electric sandwich maker features a 12’’ x 12’’ x 6’’ cooking surface that is wide enough for making 2 sandwiches in a turn. It can even cut down the middle of both sandwiches, then seal all ingredients inside.

Gotham Steel Specifications

Weight

0.01 Ounces

Dimensions

6"D x 12"W x 6"H

Materials

Copper

Wattage

1400 watts

Number of Sandwiches

2

Highlight Features

The ultra-nonstick cooking surface

Indicator lights

Cool touch locking handle

Verdict

The Gotham Steel Electric Sandwich Maker has a good size for couples since it can make 2 sandwiches at a time.

Easy To Clean: Yoshikawa SJ2408

Yoshikawa SJ2408
Yoshikawa SJ2408
Pros
  • Easy to transport, use, and clean
  • Fast to heat
  • Makes crispy sandwiches
  • Quick to assemble
Cons
  • Japanese instructions
  • Short handle
  • Expensive

The Yoshikawa SJ2408 sandwich maker for a gas stove has a simple design without many hidden areas where it can collect dirt and dust over time, so it’s very easy to clean. However, this is not the main reason I listed it here.

The main body of this machine is made from fluorine resin material that is good at water-proof and non-adhesiveness, so there is no need to worry that your food will stick to the bottom. You can wash out this material with a humid cloth easily.

Yoshikawa SJ2408 Specifications

Weight

380 Grams

Dimensions

15.16"W x 1.38"H

Materials

Aluminum alloy, Fluorine resin, Phenolic resin

Number of Sandwiches

1

Highlight Features

Dishwasher

Verdict

The Yoshikawa SJ2408 Sandwich Maker for Gas Stove is made from easy-to-clean material, so it takes less effort on cleaning.

Best For Meat & Cheese Sandwiches: Happy Sales

Happy Sales
Happy Sales
Pros
  • Seals sandwiches well without leaking the ingredients inside out
  • Easy to clean and use
Cons
  • Pretty short handle

You can’t adjust the cooking temperature of a sandwich maker for gas stoves like an electric model, so are all ingredients of your meat and cheese sandwich cooked well?

The answer is yes with the Happy Sales machine. This is proven by a customer. She tried a few meat and cheese sandwiches and all of them were done cooking successfully. While the cheese melted well and the meat was warmed perfectly, each piece of bread was toasted with pretty grill marks.

Happy Sales Specifications

Weight

1.14 pounds

Dimensions

13.75 x 5.9 x 1.2 inches

Materials

Aluminum

Number of Sandwiches

1

Highlight Features

Nonstick cooking surface

Dishwasher safe

Verdict

Even without adjustable temperature settings, the Happy Sales Sandwich Maker for Gas Stoves makes sure all ingredients are cooked well.

Ultra Lightweight: Yoshikawa Atsu Atsu

Yoshikawa Atsu Atsu
Yoshikawa Atsu Atsu
Pros
  • Fast to cook
  • Even to toast
  • Easy to clean
  • Good price
  • Sturdy pan
Cons
  • Tricky to put 2 halves of the machine together after cleaning

Unlike electric breakfast sandwich makers that can automatically cook both sides of a sandwich, a sandwich maker for gas stoves requires you to flip to toast both sides. If you make sandwiches many times per day, you will appreciate the ultra lightweight Yoshikawa sandwich maker gas stove. Its weight is only 350 grams, which is lightweight enough to allow you to hold the maker long without fatigue.

Yoshikawa Atsu Atsu Specifications

Weight

350 Grams

Dimensions

L350 x W150 x H32

Materials

Aluminum

Number of Sandwiches

1

Highlight Features

Fluorine Resin Coat

Verdict

The Yoshikawa Atsu Atsu Sandwich Maker for Gas Stove is ultra lightweight, so you can comfortably hold it in your hand long.

How To Choose The Best Breakfast Sandwich Maker?

Which Type Of Breakfast Sandwich Maker Works Best For You?

Egg Sandwich Maker

This type is designed for cooking eggs only, so it is limited in functionality. However, your eggs will be in good shape to fit in slices of bread, croissants, English muffins, and buns perfectly. This option suits small kitchens because it is the smallest-sized type in this list.

Layered Sandwich Maker

This machine allows you to stack many ingredients for one sandwich in a turn. Thus, it helps you shorten your sandwich-making process instead of preparing each step separately. You not only can save more time but also wouldn’t cause a mess.

Dual Breakfast Sandwich Maker

As the name suggests, this sandwich maker allows you to prepare 2 sandwiches at a time. So, you can save more time compared to when making twice with a single sandwich maker.

Multipurpose Sandwich Maker

It is the most versatile sandwich maker because this machine can handle different food items. It is good for busy families and food business owners.

What Size Of The Breakfast Sandwich Maker Is Ideal For You?

To determine this aspect, you have to know how much space you can spend for a sandwich maker in your kitchen and how much food you need for a sandwich.

A big model can hold bigger sandwich slices with a large amount of food while smaller units work well for bagels and English muffins.

Note: if you need to prepare sandwiches for a big family, some allow you to make 4 in a go.

Is Power An Important Consideration?

Yes, because power determines the cooking and heating speed. For this aspect, high power is always the top priority since it helps you prepare your breakfast quicker and more effectively. Normally, 700-750 watts are a perfect power range, but some can go higher than this level.

Do You Want To Spend More Money On A Model With Adjustable Heat Settings?

For me, the answer is yes. As you know, different foods have different ideal cooking temperature levels. This feature allows you to customize the cooking temperature depending on what you are handling. You can cook your food properly, but it might cost you more.

What Are The Features Of A Safe Handle?

Though most breakfast sandwich makers are designed with handles, not all of them are the same. You should choose high-quality plastic handles that can keep you safer when using this machine because this material doesn’t conduct electricity and heat well. In particular, it won’t melt when exposed to the heat for a long time. Also, if possible, consider an ergonomic and easy-to-clean handle for more convenience.

What Is Your Favorite Sandwich Shape?

Your answer helps you choose a suitable plate shape. You have the following options: rectangular, triangular, and half-round plate shapes. Even some of them come with a grilling plate or a waffle-maker plate.

Do You Need The Support Of Indicator Lights?

This function is extremely useful for beginners who have had little experience in making sandwiches with a maker. It can tell you when your food has reached a desired temperature. So, there is no need to worry about overcooking your sandwich.

Which Brands Make The Best Breakfast Sandwich Maker?

Hamilton Beach

In 1910, Hamilton Beach was founded in Wisconsin by Louis Hamilton and Chester Beach.

With over 100 years of experience, this is one of the most famous brands in America because of their reasonable and high-quality kitchen appliances. Some of their product lines include ice cream makers, slow cookers, coffeemakers, and blenders.

FAQs

What is the difference between a sandwich maker and waffle maker?

While the waffle maker makes only one waffle at a time, the sandwich maker can make more pieces of sandwiches (4-6) in one go. So, the latter helps you save more time.

Although the waffle maker has more versions, it is more expensive than a sandwich maker.

The sandwich maker takes less time to make sandwiches, so it uses less power than a waffle maker that takes you about 6-7 minutes to make a single waffle.

The sandwich maker comes with many sizes from small to bigger ones. Meanwhile, most waffle makers are small, so it’s easy to carry for a picnic.

Can I fry an egg in a sandwich maker?

Yes, you can. This way helps you fry eggs with less oil, especially, the frying process can be done faster than cooking in a skillet. However, be sure to preheat your sandwich maker before adding the eggs and use a plate to keep your eggs from running out.

Can you use bagels in a breakfast sandwich maker?

Yes, you can. However, preheat the machine before adding your bagels.

Can I make waffles in a sandwich maker?

Yes, you can make waffles in a sandwich maker, but you have to sacrifice the classic holes like what is on a normal waffle shape. And nothing else will change in the taste.

In a normal case, a sandwich maker works faster than a waffle maker, but it’s not quick to use a sandwich machine for making a waffle. You take even longer (10 minutes) compared to when making a waffle in a waffle machine (5 minutes). Everything happens for a reason that is the sandwich maker produces a bigger, thicker, and puffier waffle.

How do you make breakfast sandwiches in a machine?

There are many breakfast sandwiches you can try on the Internet and check the way to make on the included instructions of each model.

Conclusion

Many people still wonder about buying the best breakfast sandwich maker because they can make a perfect sandwich with a pan. This is right and you don’t need one if you rarely eat this kind of food.

However, if sandwiches are your favorite breakfast and you want to try many versions of sandwiches on the Internet, buy one. It can not only provide you with a quick and tasty breakfast everyday but also make other dishes like waffles. Some of them even can grill meat like chicken and beef for your family’s small parties.

Jane Orta
Jane Orta

Related Articles